Font Size: A A A

Conferences


2002 Financial Markets Conference - Venture Capital and Technology: What's Next?

Financial Markets Conference
Jointly sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
and the New York University Leonard N. Stern School of Business

The Cloister
Sea Island, Georgia
May 2–4, 2002

Program

One of the hallmarks of the recent expansion was the formation of technically related firms and the development of financial market innovations, especially venture capital markets, to support them. Technological innovation, the spread of communications, wireless and internet technologies, and the growth of new firms to exploit these capabilities offer the promise to provide new products and services as well as expanded opportunities for existing firms. This has, on the one hand, significantly affected the rate of productivity growth in the economy. At the same time the prospects for new technologies have affected securities markets, which first responded exuberantly to the potential of these technologies and then burst. The advances in technology and the market’s response to them have complicated the formulation of monetary policy as the Federal Reserve has attempted to determine how much these developments have permanently altered the economy’s potential growth path and how the newly generated wealth has affected spending and consumption. These issues are especially important given the recent path of economic activity and uncertainty about the current productivity path.

This conference seeks to understand the innovation process and the financial mechanisms that make it possible. At its heart is the venture capital industry, which has its historical roots in the process of technology. We will explore these links and what may be done to harness their positive influences and investigate whether there is a role for public policy in the process.


Thursday, May 2 (Academic Sessions)
Welcome and overview
Robert A. Eisenbeis, Senior Vice President and Director of Research, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
Ari Ginsberg, Director, Berkley Center for Entrepreneurial Studies, Stern School of Business, New York University
Paper I: “An Index for Venture Capital

Chair: Gerald P. Dwyer Jr., Vice President, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
Presenter: Susan E. Woodward, Founder, Sand Hill Econometrics, Menlo Park, California
Discussant: Bruce N. Lehmann, Professor of Finance and Economics, University of California, San Diego
Paper II: “Venture Capital Contracts and Market Structure

Chair: Stephen D. Smith, H. Talmage Dobbs Jr. Chair in Finance, Georgia State University
Presenter: Holger M. Müller, Assistant Professor of Finance, Stern School of Business, New York University
Discussant: Albert S. Kyle, Professor of Finance, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina
Paper III: “Start-up Financing: Banks versus Venture Capital

Chair: Larry D. Wall, Financial Economist and Policy Adviser, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
Presenter: Augustin Landier, Graduate Student, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge
Discussant: Masako Ueda, Assistant Professor of Financial Economics, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Paper IV: “Venture Capitalists as Benevolent Vultures: The Role of Network Externalities in Financing Choice

Chair: Iftekhar Hasan, Professor of Finance, New Jersey Institute of Technology and Rutgers University, Newark
Presenter: Dima Leshchinskii, Assistant Professor, Haute Etudes Commerciales (HEC) School of Management, Paris
Session Paper | Presentation
Discussant: Kose John, Charles William Gerstenberg Professor of Banking and Finance, Stern School of Business, New York University
Keynote speaker, by videoconference:
Stock Options and Related Matters
Alan Greenspan, Chairman, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
Friday, May 3 (Policy Sessions - Day One)
POLICY SESSION I: External versus Internal Venturing

Corporations and the Financing of Innovation: The Corporate Venturing Experience
Given the success of the U.S. venture capital industry, major corporations have sought ways to duplicate the experience by internal venturing, joint ventures, strategic alliances, and outright purchase. What is there about the venture capital model that seems to be so difficult for large firms to duplicate internally? Is it the invention or innovation process? Has the process of financial innovation changed the way that information flows within a company so that different models now better enable managers to monitor projects and control agency problems? Is it related to issues of corporate governance, mentoring, and control? What models of internal venturing have survived the test of time and been successful? What impact has the economic slowdown had on corporate venturing? How does one duplicate that experience across a wide variety of economic activities outside of the technology sphere? What are the conflicts facing participants in external venturing activities? What are the costs, benefits, and risks to both parties in corporate venturing? Are there antitrust issues and concerns?

Moderator: Lisa A. Broderick, Managing Partner, Conversus Group, New York
Presentation
Presenter: Paul A. Gompers, Professor of Business Administration, Harvard Business School, Cambridge
Session Paper | Presentation
Discussants: Warren Holtsberg, Corporate Vice President, Motorola Ventures, Schaumburg, Illinois
Presentation
Ronald H. Peele, Vice President, AOL Time Warner Ventures, Dulles, Virginia
Presentation

POLICY SESSION II: Valuation and Performance

Venture Capital and the Internet Bubble: Facts, Fundamentals, and Food for Thought
During the 1990s, venture capital played a major role in the technology boom as unprecedented amounts of capital flowed into new ventures, especially computers and related technologies. It is now clear with hindsight that a speculative bubble developed in that sector. Valuations by the initial providers of financing to new ventures and subsequently by the market seemed decoupled from fundamentals when new firms, many of which had never earned positive profits, went public and saw their initial public offering valuations double and triple in value within a very short time. What happened to traditional risk assessment, valuation techniques, and performance measurement of investments during this bubble? What are institutional investors doing with their venture funding activities now that the area has slowed? What role do the various players—the venture capitalists, investment banks, and venture capital funds—now play in the process? What have we learned? Could it happen again and is it likely? If so, where? Biotech? Energy generation? Or some currently lesser-known technology?

Moderator: Susan E. Woodward, Founder, Sand Hill Econometrics, Menlo Park, California
Presenter: Thomas Hellmann, Visiting Assistant Professor, University of Pennsylvania, and Assistant Professor of Strategic Management, Stanford University
Session Paper | Presentation
Discussants: Philippa Malmgren, Special Assistant to the President of the United States, National Economic Council, Washington, D.C.
Thomas C. Melzer, Cofounder and Managing Director, RiverVest Venture Partners, St. Louis, Missouri
Paper Comments


Saturday, May 4 (Policy Sessions - Day Two)

POLICY SESSION III: Venture Capital, Innovation, and Economic Growth

Boom and Bust in the Venture Capital Industry and the Impact on Innovation
Most of the job creation and new innovations in the United States tend to come from smaller companies. What role have venture capital activities played in fostering economic growth and stimulating innovation? What role can they play? What has been the record of sources and deployment of new innovations? Have venture capital activities stimulated local and regional growth? What is the necessary infrastructure to make this venturing process workable? It’s clear from the experiences in Silicon Valley and in the Route 128 Boston area that both a critical mass of investors and new ventures are necessary for a vibrant community of new ventures to succeed. What are the key components of this infrastructure? And what can be done, as a matter of public policy, to perhaps promote and encourage the growth of new ventures and their associated funding sources?

Moderator: Susan Schmidt Bies, Member, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
Presenter: Josh Lerner, Jacob H. Schiff Professor of Investment Banking, Harvard Business School, Cambridge
Session Paper | Presentation
Discussants: F. Mark Modzelewski, Founder and Executive Director, NanoBusiness Alliance, New York
Presentation
Calvin R. Stiller, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Medical Discoveries Fund Inc., London, Ontario
Presentation


POLICY SESSION IV: International Experience

Engineering a Venture Capital Market: Strategies for Replicating the U.S. Template
Many aspects of the U.S. venture capital industry are unique when compared with the rest of the world. What is it that explains these differences and the success in generating new innovations and growth opportunities? Are the answers in aspects of financial or corporate structure, in labor mobility, in finance vehicles available? Is it a matter of government regulation and support or lack thereof? Are there other countries with comparable models and if so, what explains their success as compared with the United States? Do these comparisons suggest any policy implications?

Moderator: Catherine L. Mann, Senior Fellow, Institute for International Economics, Washington, D.C.
Presenter: Ronald J. Gilson, Marc and Eva Stern Professor of Law and Business, Columbia Law School, New York
Session Paper
Discussants: Patricia M. Cloherty, Chairman, The U.S. Russia Investment Fund, New York
Paper Comments
John K. Thompson, Financial Counselor, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris
Presentation | Paper Comments

 

Related Links


Related Links on Other Sites