EconSouth (Fourth Quarter 2004)
Hurricanes Raise Questions About
Hammered by four hurricanes in the fall of 2004, Florida now faces a variety of economic challenges. Not since 1964 has the state been hit by multiple storms over such a short period.
|Photo courtesy of the Federal Emergency Management Agency|
From mid-August through late September 2004, hurricanes Charley, Frances, Ivan, and Jeanne plowed through Florida, killing dozens of people and causing billions of dollars in damages. Together the four storms created the worst hurricane losses since 1992, when Andrew roared through southern Florida. Not to be forgotten, however, are the impacts beyond the Sunshine State. Southern Alabama also suffered severe damage from Hurricane Ivan, and heavy storms rained down on parts of Mississippi, Louisiana, and Georgia. But the bulk of the damage was in Florida, and the economic impact there is considerable.
Floridas economy has been an engine of growth not only for the Southeast but for the United States. In fact, Florida added jobs in 2002 and 2003 when the nation as a whole continued to see employment levels decline (see chart 1). During the past year the rest of the country has started to recover and by several measures has caught up with Florida. Nevertheless, through October, more than 40 percent of all U.S. payroll gains since the end of the recession were in Florida. The question is whether the 2004 hurricanes have derailed Floridas booming economy.
|The hurricanes immediate impact on Floridas economy was clearly negative as storm damage and power losses curtailed economic activity. The downturn should not last long, however, and the states economy will likely perform well in 2005.|
|Photo courtesy of UltimateChase.com|
Even though hurricane damage was severe in a few areas, large-scale economic disruptions will probably be short-lived. Higher insurance deductibles and inadequate flood coverage may have affected consumers pocketbooks enough to have a negative impact on consumer spending in the short term, but reconstruction outlays will likely make up for any temporary slowdown. Damage to agricultural areas, on the other hand, may take longer to mend, and the outlook for tourism poses a number of unanswered questions.
Assessing the immediate damage
Insurance companies are paying over two million claims in Floridanearly three times the number of claims from Hurricane Andrew in 1992to customers whose property was damaged or destroyed by the 2004 hurricanes. The Insurance Information Institute estimates that payments for storm damage will be between $22 billion and $23 billion, surpassing the $20 billion paid out in the wake of Andrew (see chart 2). The institute also estimates that more than one out of every five Florida homes has been damaged by the hurricanes.
The impact on employment. But placing a dollar amount on the damage does not adequately measure the hurricanes overall effect on Floridas economy. The impact on employment is also an important indicator.
Gathering data to adequately measure the hurricanes effect on jobs is difficult, and it may be well into 2005 before a clearer picture emerges. Estimates of payroll employment are reduced only when people have been off work for an entire pay period and not paid for the time missed. While some employed persons were off payrolls during the survey reference period for reasons related to the hurricanes effects, some jobs were added as part of recovery efforts. Of course, the Bureau of Labor Statistics household survey showed that unemployment spiked in the most affected areas in the immediate wake of the storms but has since declined.
|Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta|
One employment indicator that was immediately measurable was a huge spike in initial unemployment insurance claims. New claimants jumped in the late summer as a result of the hurricanes. Weekly data show that initial claims had dropped back to prehurricane levels by mid-November.
Looking beyond Florida. The impact of the hurricanes will likely be felt beyond the Sunshine State. For example, the rebuilding that pulls construction materials and labor to Florida and southern Alabama may push up prices for these goods and services in nonaffected areas as well as damaged areas of the Southeast and even in areas beyond the region. An increase in prices in the immediate wake of storms is not unexpected as supply moves to catch up with increased demand. Anecdotal evidence and the fact that construction was already at very healthy levels before the hurricanes lead many analysts to believe that prices may remain elevated into 2005.
Oil production in the Gulf of Mexico is still reeling in the wake of Ivan. Oil rig shutdowns and evacuations as the hurricane approached caused expected disruptions, but these were exacerbated by damage to underwater pipelines. Most of the repairs to damaged drilling rigs and production platforms in the Gulf have been completed, but nine rigs remain out of commission at press time. More importantly, pipeline damage caused by Ivan has shut off nearly 6 percent of the Gulf of Mexicos annual oil production as of early November. Industry experts fear that it may take several months for repairs to the pipeline to be completed.
Determining the outlook
Even though the precise toll on Floridas economy may not be known at this point, some general assumptions can be made. Clearly, the economic impact was initially negative during the first several weeks following each hurricane as normal patterns of economic activity were disrupted. But by the fourth quarter of 2004 reconstruction was under way, and the economic impact turned more positive.
Overall, the states economy will likely recover quickly. Floridas strong employment and demographic trends should persist despite storm damage. In fact, during the near term, employment may well increase as workers are added in emergency services, cleanup, and construction.
As devastating as the hurricanes were, a number of businesses are benefiting. From firms that provide emergency preparedness analysis and training to businesses that furnish products and services to help in the reconstruction, a number of companies are well positioned to take advantage of rising demand for their services. Many new construction jobs may be created in the rebuilding effort, and job gains may also occur in other industries such as retail, utilities, business services, and insurance.
Insurance Payments for the
10 Costliest U.S. Hurricanes
|Source: Insurance Information Institute|
A number of other factors need to be considered before the final assessment of the economic impact of the 2004 hurricanes can be made, however. The capacity of Floridas economy to escape long-term damage will depend on how quickly the infrastructure is restored. Expeditious repairs will support the areas recovery, but delays in rebuilding infrastructure or facilities could result in longer-lasting economic damage. In addition, different industries face diverse challenges.
Construction. Developments already under way and those on the drawing board may be delayed as resources are diverted toward rebuilding. But rebuilding could have beneficial effects if the new construction generates additional investment and improvements in the physical infrastructure. One probable long-term outcome of 2004s storms in Florida and Alabama will be that less sturdily built houses, including mobile homes and manufactured housing, will be replaced with stronger structures better able to withstand hurricane-force winds. This added investment ultimately will improve the quality of the housing stock, generate greater property tax revenue, and entice residents to the area.
Manufacturing. Although only 2.7 percent of Floridas workers are employed in manufacturing, the sector was not untouched by the storms. Reports from manufacturers suggest that some smaller operations were hurt, but larger establishments were only temporarily disrupted by the hurricanes. Transportation delays with regard to receiving supplies had a more serious and lingering impact on manufacturers than actual storm damage did.
Tourism. Floridas tourism industry may face stiffer competition for vacation dollars in the aftermath of the hurricanes. Destinations outside Florida could benefit from nervousness about visiting the state. Over the longer term, there are worries that the flow of retirees moving from Northern states may taper off, or perhaps businesses pondering relocating to the state may reconsider. Its too early to tell if these concerns will materialize, but Floridas tourism industry officials have allocated millions of dollars to an advertising campaign designed to reassure vacationers, retirees, and executives that Florida remains a prime location for recreation, comfort, and business.
Thom Stork, president and CEO of the Florida Aquarium in Tampa and chairman-elect of Visit Florida, a private/public partnership established to promote Florida tourism, feels that the states tourism industry is in good shape. Florida is up and running and open for business, he said. Even in areas that were hit by the hurricanes, repairs are being made and most damaged hotels and resorts are back open. He also noted that winter business has been very good so far, and he did not expect that pattern to change. In Palm Beach, for example, 2005 advance bookings for large resorts are running ahead of the previous years levels.
Photo courtesy of the Federal Emergency Management Agency
|One probable long-term outcome of 2004's storms in Florida and Alabama will be that less sturdily build houses, including mobile homes and manufactured housing, will be replaced with stronger structures better able to withstand hurricane-force winds.|
The hurricanes ultimate effect on tourism may well depend on how much damage was done to Floridas reputation. The most affected areas of the states tourism lodging industry are all in minor markets, according to Scott Berman, a partner in the global hospitality and leisure consulting practice with PricewaterhouseCoopers. The hardest-hit lodging markets, which include Pensacola, Melbourne, and Port Charlotte, are all relatively small compared to other Florida markets, he said. Floridas major destinationsMiami, Fort Lauderdale, Orlando, Tampa, and Napleshave been largely unaffected. Some hotels and resorts in these markets suffered modest damage, but all were up and running in short order.
Economic damage to the cruise industry is yet another factor. Royal Caribbean Cruises, which canceled three cruises and switched routes on seven others, said Frances was the most disruptive storm in the lines 33-year history. The Miami-based company announced that costs from the storm have hurt profits. Other cruise lines faced similar challenges.
Whether the four hurricanes will have a long-term effect on tourists plans to visit Florida is unclear. A survey issued by the Orlando-based travel marketing, advertising, and public relations firm of Yesawich, Pepperdine, Brown & Russell shows that there may be some negative fallout. The study, conducted on the heels of Hurricane Jeanne, revealed that 5 percent of travelers who had plans to visit the state prior to the arrival of the hurricanes cancelled trips as a result. An additional 4 percent postponed a trip. More importantly, 20 percent reported that they were less likely to visit Florida in the remainder of 2004, and a comparable percentage indicated they were less likely to visit the state between July and September of 2005. In addition, tourism officials also worry that meeting and convention bookers may choose other locations for their events. Florida officials are developing an insurance product that would cover potential losses to organizations should their conventions be postponed because of hurricanes.
Visit Florida survey research found that 20 percent of potential visitors were concerned about returning to the state during 2005s hurricane season. If all those people stayed away, it would result in a $6.7 billion loss in expenditures, Stork said.
Agriculture. Hurricane damage to Florida farms was estimated at nearly $3 billion. The U.S. Department of Agriculture reported that Florida orange production levels were 27 percent lower than last years, and the grapefruit harvest was 63 percent lower. Industry contacts expect only a moderate impact on the price of orange juice because of strong global supply conditions. The longer-term outlook for citrus production could be threatened by tree damage and the potential spread of disease.
Hurricanes in Florida in 2004
In addition, Florida is the nations largest producer of greenhouse and nursery plants, which generated cash receipts of approximately $1.6 billion in 2003. The hurricanes hit key production areas, with damages reportedly ranging from $400 million to $600 million.
Storm damage to Floridas cattle industry is estimated to be between $100 million and $150 million. There were few direct cattle losses, but damage to farm and ranch structures and forage crops was severe.
Consumer spending. The hurricanes short-term effect on consumer spending may be modest. Increased spending for prestorm stockpiling of emergency goods and repair purchases after the hurricane may turn out to be more significant than the loss of sales during the storms and their aftermath. The hurricanes effects may prove more significant with regard to the pattern of spending than the amount.
The storms longer-term impact is somewhat uncertain. Because most insurance contracts treat each storm as a separate event, some homeowners are contending with multiple deductibles from damage by separate storms. In addition, changes in insurance rules since Andrew include the restructuring of deductible payments from a fixed-dollar value to a percentage of the total claim, which raises the deductible share of large claims.
Nevertheless, Floridas retailers are optimistic. According to a recent survey, 75 percent of Florida retailers expect the fourth quarter to be similar or better than the same quarter last year, said Rick McAllister, president and CEO of the Florida Retail Federation.
Smaller retailers in hard-hit areas are facing their own set of problems, McAllister noted. While acknowledging that many consumers facing large deductibles have experienced severe dents in their wallets, the overall outlook for consumer spending in the state as a whole is positive.
What about the less fortunate?
Along with the larger view of Floridas economy, it is also important to remember that natural disasters affect different people in different ways. Estimated recovery periods will be significantly different for low- to moderate-income households. Those with adequate insurance and cash on hand will be back on their feet in short order, but for the less affluent, recovery may take much longer.
The hurricanes took a large toll on some of Floridas poorer regions. Recent data from the U.S. Census Bureau show that hard-hit Escambia County, which includes the city of Pensacola, replaced Miami-Dade in 2003 as Floridas poorest county. In fact, Escambia County is the 17th poorest county in the nation, according to census figures. Nearly 56,000 people19 percent of the countys total populationlived below the poverty line in 2003.
|Photo courtesy of the Federal Emergency Management Agency|
The decline in manufacturing employmentespecially in the chemical and paper industries, which typically pay higher wages than do the industries serving Escambia Countys large tourist and retirement communitieshas played a role in lowering the cost of living and pushing up the level of poverty in the county.
In addition to those living in poverty, many Floridians exist just above the poverty line. Although some of these less affluent workers may have jobs as part of the cleanup and reconstruction in the hurricanes aftermath, many of them depend on fixed incomes or weekly paychecks from jobs in the hard-hit retail and tourism industries. Because the storms destroyed or severely damaged their places of work, a number of these low-income wage earners may not be receiving paychecks for some time. Many small businesses will never reopen, and their employees will be forced to find work elsewhere.
Private and government relief efforts will help many of the poor, but not all. Thousands of illegal immigrant laborers risk falling through the cracks of disaster recovery. Some undocumented workers may fear that they will face deportation if they seek aid, and many others may be unaware that help is available.
The pressure less affluent people face in simply earning a living in the wake of the hurricanes is exacerbated by the fact that many have sustained severe damage to their homes. Many live in mobile or trailer homes, and the older of these homes were harder hit than traditional structures.
According to 2000 U.S. Census data, Florida has nearly 850,000 mobile homes, accounting for about 12 percent of the states single-family housing stock. The Florida Manufactured Housing Association reports that this number may be low, noting that 19 percent is probably more accurate.
Short-term downturn, long-term questions
The hurricanes immediate impact on Floridas economy was clearly negative as storm damage and power losses curtailed economic activity. The downturn should not last long, however, and the states economy will likely perform well in 2005. Yet a number of unanswered questions remain, including what long-term impact the disasters will have on Floridas important tourism and agriculture sectors as well as the impact on the less affluent.
While making hard economic assessments of natural disasters, it is vital to keep in mind the human cost in terms of deaths, injuries, damaged property, and disrupted lives. The people of Florida and other affected areas have faced challenges difficult to imagine and impossible to calculate in cold economic terms. Nevertheless, Floridas economy is recovering, and its citizens are pulling through.
This article was written by Michael Chriszt, director of international and regional analysis for the regional group of the Atlanta Fed's research department.